In the crowded field of business literature, Good Strategy Bad Strategy by Richard Rumelt stands out as a beacon of clarity and insight. This seminal work, published in 2011, is not just another manual on strategic planning; it is a deep dive into the essence of what makes a strategy effective and, conversely, why so many strategic plans fail. Drawing on decades of experience and research, Rumelt provides a compelling narrative that dissects the good, the bad, and the ugly of strategic thinking.
Good Strategy Bad Strategy is divided into three main parts: Good and Bad Strategy, Sources of Power, and Thinking Like a Strategist. Each section builds on the previous one, creating a comprehensive framework that is both practical and theoretical.
Good and Bad Strategy: Rumelt begins by explaining what constitutes a good strategy and what doesn't. He introduces the concept of the "kernel" of a good strategy, which includes a diagnosis, a guiding policy, and coherent actions. He contrasts this with bad strategy, characterised by fluff, failure to face challenges, mistaking goals for strategy, and bad strategic objectives.
Sources of Power: This section explores the sources of strategic power that can be harnessed to overcome obstacles and achieve objectives. Rumelt delves into leveraging advantages, focusing on growth opportunities, and using design to create powerful strategies. He provides numerous case studies and examples to illustrate these concepts in action.
Thinking Like a Strategist: In the final section, Rumelt offers insights into how to develop strategic thinking skills. He emphasises the importance of diagnosis and the ability to discern patterns and changes in complex situations. Rumelt also addresses common pitfalls and biases that can derail strategic thinking.
Key Takeaways
The Kernel of a Good Strategy: At the heart of a good strategy is the "kernel," which Rumelt defines as a simple, yet powerful concept that includes a diagnosis of the situation, a guiding policy to address the diagnosis, and coherent actions to implement the policy. This clear framework helps in cutting through the noise and focusing on what truly matters.
Clarity Over Fluff: One of the most striking critiques Rumelt makes is against what he calls "fluff"—the tendency to use grandiose language without substance. A good strategy is clear, concise, and actionable, free from vague and meaningless jargon.
Facing Challenges Head-On: Rumelt argues that a key difference between good and bad strategy is the willingness to face challenges directly. A good strategy does not shy away from acknowledging and addressing obstacles. Instead, it uses them as a basis for developing robust and realistic plans.
Strategic Leverage: Effective strategies often leverage existing strengths and opportunities. Rumelt highlights the importance of focusing resources on areas where they can have the most significant impact, rather than spreading them too thinly across numerous initiatives.
Adaptability and Learning: The ability to adapt and learn is crucial in strategic thinking. Rumelt emphasises the need for continuous evaluation and adjustment of strategies in response to changing circumstances and new information.
Critical Analysis
Richard Rumelt's Good Strategy Bad Strategy is a masterclass in strategic thinking. Its strength lies in its clear and practical framework, which is grounded in real-world examples and case studies. Rumelt's writing is both accessible and authoritative, making complex concepts understandable and actionable for readers at all levels.
However, the book is not without its critiques. Some readers might find Rumelt's examples heavily skewed towards large corporations and significant geopolitical events, which may seem distant from the challenges faced by small businesses or startups. Additionally, the depth of analysis can sometimes feel overwhelming, requiring readers to invest time and effort to fully grasp the concepts.
Conclusion
Good Strategy Bad Strategy by Richard Rumelt is an essential read for anyone involved in strategic planning and decision-making. It offers a clear and insightful guide to distinguishing between effective and ineffective strategies, backed by thorough research and practical examples. Whether you are a seasoned executive, a budding entrepreneur, or a student of business, this book provides valuable lessons that can enhance your strategic thinking and execution.
In a world where bad strategy often masquerades as good, Rumelt's work is a much-needed reminder of what true strategic thinking looks like. It is a call to cut through the noise, face challenges head-on, and craft strategies that are both clear and impactful. If you are serious about mastering the art of strategy, Good Strategy Bad Strategy should be at the top of your reading list.
You can find Good Strategy Bad Strategy by Richard Rumelt on Amazon UK.
Comments